Moonlighting: A $16.8 billion monster with many tentacles

Moonlighting: A 16.8 billion dollar monster with many tentacles

UPDATE DAY

“You can pay me cash, otherwise I will have to add the taxes. This is the kind of phrase that we are likely to hear more and more often with inflation which has reached a 30-year high, while the size of the underground economy is already approaching $20 billion.  

“As part of the 2022-2023 budget, the Ministère des Finances estimated the size of the underground economy in Quebec at $16.8 billion for 2019 and the resulting tax losses for the Quebec state at $2.8 billion. $”, explains to the Journal Jacques Delorme, spokesperson for the Ministry of Finance.

While inflation reached 7.3% last month after crossing a peak of 8% in June, work under the table becomes much more attractive, according to experts consulted by Le Journal.

“If there are companies that can easily compete under the table, it will one day hurt those that don't. It will complicate their recruitment. That's what scares me,” warns Richard Gaudreault, partner in the Labor and Employment Law group at Lavery.

“Inflation could lead companies to go in this direction- the. This is why the government must be vigilant,” he adds.

“Inflation is likely to favor the increase in undeclared work”, also thinks Bernard Cliche, lawyer emeritus in labor relations at Morency.

Moonlighting: A 16.8 billion dollar monster with many tentacles

Bernard Cliche
Labour Lawyer Emeritus

A real magnet

For Jean-Claude Bernatchez, full professor of labor relations at the University of Quebec at Trois-Rivières (UQTR), undeclared work acts like a real magnet.

“The more the cost of labor is high [salary and social charges], the more tempting it is for an employer to turn to undeclared work,” he says.

“As the tax is progressive, and even exponential, it can be tempting for the employees”, underlines the director of the Labor Relations Observatory.

For his part, Bernard Fortin, professor of economics at Laval University, recalls that the phenomenon remains very difficult to measure.

Self-employed workers

The man who wrote a vast study on the subject 20 years ago is rather of the opinion that the opposite could even happen in a period of high inflation.

“We are in a situation of very strong competition, which tends to bring down the underground economy”, he analyzes.

Moonlighting: A 16.8 billion dollar monster with many tentacles

Bernard Fortin
Professor of economics

“Undeclared work is found a lot among people who are self-employed,” he continues.

According to him, the black worker resembles the figure of the “free rider”.

Moonlighting: A 16.8 billion dollar monster with many tentacles

Moonlighting: A 16.8 billion dollar monster with many tentacles

“While often adapting very well to the public services he consumes, he does not participate equitably in their financing. On the social level, the generalization of the phenomenon can lead to a loss of confidence in the law as well as a weakening of democracy”, could we read in his study, which has not aged a bit.

Industries Affected

In the world of auto repair, François Paradis, who waters the job site Mécanicien.ca, finds that inflation play the spoilsport.

“There will definitely be more. Everyone tries to save as much as they can. Everything went up, so no 15% tax on $1,000, it's $150,” he blurts out.

At the Association of Construction and Housing Professionals of Quebec (APCHQ), we claim to want to fight undeclared work.

“Among the sectors of activity in the underground economy in Quebec and in Canada, residential construction ranks first,” reads a 2018 study by the cluster.

Encouraging fact, according to the APCHQ, if between 2011 and 2016 the GDP, the underground economy and investments in renovation jumped by 15%, 10% and 18%, underground residential construction would have declined by 3%.

►APCHQ believes that the introduction of renovation tax credits since 2013 has reduced the use of undeclared work.

“At least a quarter of self-employed workers” in Quebec give in to temptation and thwart the taxman

Caroline Bédard, CEO of TAQ, calls for the abolition of the “$30,000 rule”. She explains that lowering this ceiling to zero would drastically reduce undeclared work and increase the credibility of the self-employed worker.

An association lifts the veil on the taboo of undeclared work among self-employed workers by daring to say out loud that many of them would evade the taxman by ignoring the “$30,000 rule”.

“It's tempting for a self-employed person. We get along,” admits Caroline Bédard, CEO of Autonomous Workers Quebec (TAQ).

“At least a quarter of the 565,000 self-employed workers do it,” says the one who heads a 200-member association aimed at pushing the state to recognize, once and for all, the status of self-employed workers. 

“Hairdressers, beauticians, massage therapists, manicurists… are often paid either in cash or by bank transfer, so it's sometimes easier”, illustrates Caroline Bédard bluntly.

< p>While omerta reigns in the world of self-employed workers, Ms. Bédard does not budge: you have to burst the abscess to get things moving.

The $30,000 rule< /strong>

“If someone does websites, it's more difficult because the client wants to have an invoice, but when you come up with the quick services, like dog grooming, it may be easier to black out,” she continues.

“Someone who earns less than $30,000 [per year] doesn't have to charge GST and QST, so it's very easy to mention that you earn $28,000,” explains the woman. , who writes for a local media.

According to her, lowering this ceiling to zero would make it possible to melt moonlighting like snow in the sun in addition to increasing the credibility of the self-employed worker.  

“A self-employed worker sometimes has trouble going to the bank to buy a house because it's harder to commit to his turnover. That would help”, explains Caroline Bédard.

For Gervais Bisson, president of the Professional Association of Hairdressing Employers of Quebec (APECQ), Ms. Bédard is hitting the target. 

“We are losing our employees who ask us for black. The government knows it. In chair rental, more than 99% of landlords and tenants are illegal,” he argues.

►In a brief tabled in the House of Commons, TAQ goes so far as to say that the fact of not recognizing the status of self-employed worker results in outright “discrimination”. 

< /p>

“Sharing economy” enthusiasts not immune 

Airbnb, Uber, Lyft… Workers in new “sharing economy” companies also have tax obligations, reminds the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA).

“As a participant in the platform economy, you could be considered a self-employed person operating a business. In this case, your tax obligations are different from those you would have if you were an employee”, underlines the federal organization.

A self-employed person must declare his income, pay the tax due, contribute to the Quebec Pension Plan and keep an accounting register.

If he declares less than $30,000 in income per year, the “small supplier” does not have to register in the files of the GST and QST.

Influencers too

Subscriptions, advertising, sponsorships, sales of merchandise, products, clothing, travel and other gifts… 

On social media, influencers engage in commercial activities when these “include an element of profit and that they are undertaken in a sufficiently organized and commercial manner”. 

THE 4 TYPES OF PLATFORM ECONOMIES 

1. Sharing Economy 

Using or sharing personal property to earn income (Airbnb, Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, etc.). 

2. Economy on demand 

Freelance or short-term work (Clickworker, Crowdsource, Fiverr, etc.). 

3. Peer to Peer (P2P) 

Sale of goods from one person or party directly to another (through 'Etsy, eBay, Amazon, etc.). 

4. Social Media Influencers 

Revenue earned through social media from advertising revenue, subscriptions, product placement, product promotion, etc. (YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, etc.). 

Source: Canada Revenue Agency

Do you have a scoop to send us?

Do you have something to share with us about this story?

Do you have a scoop that our readers might be interested in?

Email us at or call us directly at 1 800-63SCOOP.