The right time: a Quebec solidaire candidate mixes socialism and social democracy

The right time: a candidate from Quebec solidaire mixes socialism and social- democracy

DAY

Our Investigation Office specializes in the art of establishing the facts. Throughout the election campaign, our researchers present their findings to flush out the candidates' surprising, dubious or downright false statements, and allow you to see more clearly. 

THE STATEMENT

In a tweet sent during the leaders' debate on Thursday evening, the candidate for Québec solidaire in the riding of Mille-Îles in Laval, Guillaume Lajoie, said the following: “Eric Duhaime should be reminded that Norway and the other countries of Europe that he too often mentions are socialist models.”

THE FACTS

The hour just: a candidate from Quebec solidarity mixes socialism and social democracy

That's wrong. Asked whether the Scandinavian countries were socialist models, Stéphane Paquin, professor at the National School of Public Administration (ENAP), explains that socialism advocates the socialization of the means of production, so that the State does things rather than just regulating the market. In a true socialist regime, the state owns the factories, businesses, etc.

Norway as well as Sweden, Denmark and Finland are social democratic countries. These are liberal democracies where the market plays a central role, as does entrepreneurship. There is no socialization of the means of production as in Cuba or even in Eastern Europe during the time of the USSR. That said, Stéphane Paquin recalls that to compensate for the unequal effects of the market, the Norwegian state taxes a lot to redistribute wealth. 

Asked to comment, the party mentions that its candidate spoke social democrat of the Norwegian model that Mr. Duhaime completely ignores in his analysis. “Mr. Duhaime only sees half of the Norwegian model, their investment strategy linked to their sovereign wealth fund, but never talks about the significant social expenditures that are put in place.”

  • You spotted a false or questionable statement during the election campaign? Write to us at heurejuste@quebecormedia.com and we will check the facts.