Trump wants to cancel the quarantine: but I have to make this decision and what it will bring

The President of the United States Donald trump is not hiding its desire to re-open the country, despite the fact that the number of deaths caused by a coronavirus, continues to grow, and the vaccine may receive more than a year, says USA Today.

Трамп хочет отменить карантин: вправе ли он принять такое решение и к чему это приведет

Photo frame YouTube video/Guardian News

The desire of the President to put an end to social distancing put him in an ambivalent position in relation to the opinion of his best advisers on health issues. As soon as the approaching time of the weakening of the quarantine ignite the debate about how America will emerge from the collective isolation.

April 13, trump announced its unilateral decision, opposed itself to the heads of Executive authorities in States across the country where huge increase of cases COVID-19 and mortality dictated the conditions of isolation for residents.

“This decision of the President,” trump wrote.

In fact, it is not so.

Federal law allows Washington to impose quarantine in certain circumstances and to limit travel between States, but the administration trump has not used these powers. The Supreme court stopped the attempt of the Federal government to intervene in the decisions of States.

“First and foremost, the States currently retain the right to decide who stays home and for how long, — stated in the analysis of the blog’s national security Lawfare. Among the powers usually reserved for States, has the power to put people in quarantine or otherwise to protect public health.”

The Governor of Kentucky Andy Bisher announced that people attending the Easter service will be required to isolate themselves. Senator Rand Paul and representative Thomas Massey, both Republicans from Kentucky, took the statement of the Governor as ultra vires.

Attorney General William Barr has suggested in an interview with Fox News that such restrictions are “draconian” and that the justice Department will carefully monitor the constraint to balance the needs of public health and religious freedom.

When the governors began to issue orders to stay at home

California was the first state to 19 Mar introduced a resolution on the stay at home, and this decision was followed by other governors, giving orders to various restrictions.

Arkansas is one of the few States where no such right. “If we need to do more we will do more,” said Sunday the Governor is Asa Hutchinson.

Without a Federal Directive limiting system in the country is a patchwork device, whose efforts are mainly directed to limit large gatherings and the closure of nonessential businesses. As a result, the governors and mayors has played a huge role in the crisis of the coronavirus at least two reasons: States enjoy considerable autonomy in accordance with the Constitution, and the administration of the tramp gave them a large part of the decision-making process.

When trump declared a state of emergency in the country

The President issued a Declaration of national emergency on March 13, a few days after the world health organization officially declared the coronavirus pandemic, and the administration trump has changed its original view on the flash. National emergency was separated from the trump announcement about the emergency situation in public health in late January.

This designation is formally made by the head of the Department of health and human services Alex Azar, made it easier for States the redirection of staff responding to the virus. The announcement was made in tandem with a quarantine order for US citizens returning from affected areas of China.

That means the national order of the emergency

Trump has declared a state of emergency in the country in accordance with the Stafford Act, which is used by presidents since 1988 for the Declaration of disaster zones after storms and other natural disasters. This allowed the administration to release billions of dollars from funds of the Federal emergency management Agency to combat coronavirus.

“The pandemic may lead to serious consequences for national and economic security of our country”, — said the President, announcing his decision.

Trump also invoked the national emergency provisions act which allows the Department of health and human services to modify or cancel program rules, Medicare, Medicaid, and other.

Among other things, the changes make it easier to offer telemedicine services, so patients do not need to personally come to the doctor’s office for some consultations, in spite of certain requirements of the medical licensing. This is necessary in order for doctors to provide assistance in different States and abandon the bandwidth constraints for hospitals.

When expires period of validity of orders of exclusion

Although such orders in some States, including Alabama and Kansas, due to expire in April, others have indefinite time. The Governor of Virginia Ralph Northam is ordered that the regime of isolation remained in effect until June 10.

The terms emphasize different constraint conditions in the United States. Florida and Texas have included religious services in a number of important events that have led to a potential conflict with health officials who have warned against such meetings.

Why trump is in a hurry to “open the country” after quarantine

As explained by Fox News, the President appears ready to start the “open” part of the U.S. economy the growth of unemployment to the level of the depression era. Unusual and severe restrictions imposed by the Federal, state and local authorities, led to the suspension of the economy and prompted many Americans to argue that their civil liberties are another victim of the coronavirus. People are forbidden to go to Church, to visit relatives and conduct weddings and funerals. But the main concern trump is the economy, which in three weeks has lost over 16 million jobs.

“Doctors would say, “Let’s continue closing let’s close the whole world,” said trump journalists in March. — You can’t do it with the country — especially with the economy the No. 1 in the world. It causes more problems than the disease.”

April 13, trump told reporters that he has “shared” powers in relation to when re-open the United States, and said that he believes that the economy is “off”, as soon as he gives the green light. He said he has a new task force that will focus exclusively on this task. According to the President, he holds discussions with senior helpers about what to do next with the Federal recommendations for social distancing, which expire at the end of the month. Trump said that he wants the Americans were “in complete safety”.

But with such a “restart” of the nation, there are huge risks, primarily in the fact that the deadly virus could gain momentum. Trump said that the challenge before him, is the “biggest decision” of his life.

Medical professionals from the first days of the emergence of the virus and still emphasize that the most effective way to protect yourself from the virus is to practice social distancing and proper hygiene, for example washing your hands often. But until then, until there is herd immunity, a cure or vaccine, the risk to the population is likely to remain.

Little has changed compared to the 100-page response plan, the Federal government, who in March warned that the coronavirus threat will last “18 months or longer,” according to The New York Times.

“It will not be as clicking on the switch: it’s June or July, flip a switch and the light will turn on again. It will depend on where you are in the country, the character of flash that you have already faced, and the threat of flash that you may not have faced,” explained Dr. Anthony Fauci, head of the National Institute of Allergy and infectious diseases.

Neil Kashkari, the President of the Federal reserve Bank of Minneapolis, said that at best, the US would face a mild recession, after the terrorist attacks of September 11.

“If it stops for three months, it will be over soon, he said. — If it stops during the year, it can be very harmful to the US economy, and, most importantly, for the American people.”

Trump said that the health of Americans is always in the center of his political decisions. At the beginning of April 14, at Johns Hopkins University reported that in the US there were 582 607 official cases of coronavirus infections and 23,000 deaths.

George Lowenstein, Professor of Economics and psychology at Carnegie-Mellon, said that the choice between human lives and the economy can be “false dichotomy”. According to him, it is unclear what long-term impact will have a severe depression on a person’s life.

“This will dramatically reduce the quality of human life and, of course, will also kill people, he said. — We already had unprecedented levels of mortality from despair, and if we lose generation as a result of the coronavirus a pandemic, it will have deadly consequences.”

Trump himself said that governors of States should lead the response to an outbreak of coronavirus — and for good reason. Such States as Wyoming, North Dakota, South Dakota and Montana have less than 750 cases. In new York, on the other hand, approximately 200 000 cases.

Six governors of States in the northeast formed a joint task force after an indication that the curve flattens out. The Governor of new York Andrew Cuomo, part of a group, said that the economy will have to “open” slowly.

“If you see [the infection begins to grow], so, you too, quickly opened the valve,” he said.

In addition to the health and economy of the country, another problem for some Americans was how quickly individual freedoms have been sacrificed throughout the state. The Americans were ordered to stay at home, and the state governments were requested to identify which companies are “significant” and “insignificant”.

Pastors in some southern States was on the wrong side of the law for having allegedly violated the principles of social distancing and use of public services. Some of these pastors have wondered how a grocery shop can be considered “necessary,” and the Church “optional,” the newspaper notes.

John Yoo, a law Professor at Berkeley, and Hermit Dillon, a lawyer and a representative of the Republican party, co-created the column for the Hoover institution, which States that, in accordance with the system of federalism of the Constitution, “the powers to cancel the quarantine orders are the same people that had produced governors of the state.”

“Our officials have to explain, they could implement other policies to reduce the spread of the disease without causing such massive economic destruction, — they wrote. — Take into account the impact of isolation on human health, including exacerbation of mental health problems, the projected increase in domestic violence, suicide business owners face debt and ruin? We just don’t know.”


Donald Trump



Special projects